I: introduction
to the ‘first attempt’
94. all winter
with not a word
‘What
the devil happened’, as Rev put it, after the
Fort Smith envelope: he and Jo did not find out until May
of ’71. And then, as she pointed out, ‘the dumb old news
was stale’.
“So
much for monthly envelopes,” he said in January.
“Or
telegrams,” she
added in March.
“So
much for any kind of news at all,” Rev
beefed in April.
They
suffered ‘”All
winter with nary a word.” And they were still
complaining about it years later. Because even ‘the crazy
news’ -- in the ‘crazy envelope’ from Fort Smith – that
Jack had landed in a hospital and ‘encountered’
Mortimer, who had then attempted to cure him as his
treating psychiatrist, had not reached the Lorenzos until
‘way into February’.
Jo’s
poor Jack had sent all that sad stuff from Resolution and
then gone ‘silent as death’ for months. And winter would
hit hard ‘up there’, and hit early, school teacher Jo
knew. But winter ought to give a body more time to write,
she realized. Especially if a body was mute as a body
claimed, and therefore not socializing, presumably.
“If
your naked favorite hasn’t frozen to death,” was Rev’s
comforting encouragement.
And
during the emotional days of Thanksgiving, Christmas and
New Year’s, when U.S. families all over the globe longed
to be home together beneath a warm Christmas tree; and all
through January besides: nothing. Not a
single word. Not even a little ‘crazy nonsense’, as they
complained to each other.
“A
bomb would have
been better than nothing,”
Rev said, letting Jo finish the thought.
“Because
he’s having such a
scary year!” she said.
Their
son had never failed to call or write at Christmas before the
terrible year of his ‘ridiculous remaking’. And he would
never fail after it,
either, as they would see and say proudly one day.
But an adult son should make contact at Christmas no
matter how standoffish the rest of the year.
Especially if he was having
such a terrible year.
They
both kept saying these last words because they felt
strongly about it. And he certainly had to know their
feelings; a fact which only worried them more.
Finally,
though, the so-called ‘
And
by the way: why on top of all that conundrum would he mail
something on his birthday but not at Christmas six weeks
before? That made no sense. And another thing: why would
anybody send an envelope in February about November
and not add even so much as one tiny little
word about what had happened since
November, during December and January?
“That’s
not natural,”
Jo complained.
And
the pundits agreed, some of them, but only many years
later. It seemed so very ‘unnatural’, in fact, that Jo’s
complaint would become the centerpiece of the so-called
‘Fiction Pundits’ Controversy’ when it finally hit the
tabloids in the 90’s that: if the now famous mj lorenzo
had really been
at Fort Chipewyan all winter and had mailed the Fort Smith
envelope from there in February himself, then
‘naturally’ he would have included a short note about what
had just happened between November and February, like
anyone else in the world would have done. To the ‘fiction’
pundits it looked, therefore, like mj lorenzo had been in
Or
somewhere. Writing a section of a ‘first novel’ at a time,
including within it misinformation as to his whereabouts,
maybe because he was hiding from the U.S. Vietnam War
draft (according to one theory). Probably not in
Maybe,
as they said in ‘fiction pundit’ workshops, he had given
it to someone in November. But something had gone wrong.
Somebody had screwed up. They had drunk up the postage
money on the holidays and had not scraped up postage again
until February.
But
mainstream pundits who preferred the standard view that mj
had been in
Yes,
but, said the
‘fiction’ pundits, this threw it back into ‘fiction’
again, because, as even Remaking middle-of-the-roaders
‘had to admit’, to say there might be ‘other natural
explanations’ was the same as saying that mj lorenzo might
not have been telling ‘the whole story’ in his book, The
Remaking.
At
any rate, a few months later in May, the Lorenzos would
finally get the entire ‘Part II’ of The Remaking, or
‘Freeze-Up: Seven Attempts at a Meeting’, in a single fat
envelope that was so bulky the U.S. mailman felt obliged
to ring the doorbell. The monster package was postmarked
Then
’Part III’, or ‘Break-Up’, got to them on June 30, written
and signed by ‘mj’, not ‘Jack’ or ‘Mortimer’, and mailed
from
95. ‘Sunday
School’ pundits object to the Lorenzos’ prosaic way of
referring to their son’s remaking year
Many
pundits had a bone to pick with the Lorenzos about an
unrelated point, however. From a distance, that is. For
they never would have wanted, most of them, to argue in
person with parents of their own mj. But a group did go on
record with The
Philadelphia Inquirer in the late eighties offering
the observation in an interview that ‘saying mj lorenzo
was having a bad year was like saying Jesus was having a
bad day on the day of the crucifixion’.
Most
pundits never did take to mj’s parents, usually for
reasons similar to this, for things the Lorenzos did that
showed they ‘just didn’t GET it’. They purposely kept a
distance from the Lorenzos. And Sammy’s ‘first revision’
in 1980, with its detailed revelation of the Lorenzos’
word-for-word reaction to The Remaking, years after the
fact, only annoyed some pundits further, over time, even
if they did find the parental interactions ‘ball-bustingly
funny’ from the day they were published.
But:
gradually, over the years, they came to accept that mj’s
parents never could have looked at mj or his Remaking in
the way they, the pundits, did. And they came to feel less
rancorous toward two 'nice people who would not change
their attitudes a rat’s ass-hair’, as pundits said in
private, yet ironically had given the world a
revolutionary son.
And
indeed the Lorenzos would always consider The Remaking a problem, not a
solution. They would always feel proud of mj’s
success as a psychiatrist, as a
96. grave warnings
to readers of the ‘first attempt’ from Sammy Martinez
As
for the ‘impossible first attempt’, as all referred to it:
Sammy Martinez, in his 1994 ‘second revision’, would
eventually add two notes intended to duly warn anyone
about to ‘attempt’ to read and understand it. For the
Remaking pundits had always agreed it was the very most
trying part of mj lorenzo’s Remaking, for a
variety of colorful reasons. He explained:
WARNING
TO READERS OF ‘first
attempt’
Reading the ‘first
attempt’ may jeopardize the emotional stability of anyone
short on time; patience; understanding; forgiveness;
humanity; etc., etc.
Because the ‘first
attempt’:
1) is the longest
of long chapters, unbelievably long, so long as to require
subsection AND sub-subsection
headings within itself;
2) is the most
long-winded on any given subject it addresses, or so a
vast number have complained, especially those who are
little drawn to intellectual treatises;
3) has drawn, of
any section of The Remaking, the largest number of reader
complaints of all kinds in general over the years, by far;
4) has often startled the
extremist-Christian right to tears, or at
least scandalized them into the next chapter lest they
read another disgraceful word;
5) has been hard
work too for the U.S. American left throughout
their lifetime of studying it, though they have always
understood its crucial role in The Remaking and have
always supported it;
6) is the most
emotionally discombobulating and exasperating part of The
Remaking, arguably;
7) is the least
comprehensible, in other words (but only in spots) (and
less so for certain extremist types who like that about
it); and
8) has always been
the very most dry and boring chapter of all, until, that
is, spruced up by the Dr.’s first and second revisions.”
And
then, as if he deemed even this much warning not enough,
Sammy added another strongly-worded afterthought to the 1994 Second Revision,
resorting to an attention-getting ‘you’ again and again
for emphasis:
WARNING
TO ALL SERIOUS Remaking COMMENTATORS AND
PUNDITS OFFICIALLY QUALIFIED AND AUTHORIZED OR NOT
The
next section, the notorious ‘first attempt’, chews up and
spits out commentators and pundits just as did THE
MOUNTAIN THAT REMADE MAN (the magic expanding-exploding
mountain in the Hare tale, mj’s ‘Second Dream’ on
Hungabee).1 Getting ‘chewed up’
by the mountain is not the biggest problem, however.
Neither is being ‘spit out’ by it: for, if and when you do
get ‘spit out’ and coughed out by the mountain that chewed
up and almost devoured you, you should be well on your way
to being remade.
There are, rather,
several tricks and catches to getting spit out properly
and successfully.
Like THE MOUNTAIN
THAT REMADE MAN, the ‘first attempt’ expands to infinity,
potentially. It seeks to do so by begging more and more
commentating and punditing from its reader, just as the
book of Revelation and the dreams of Daniel in the Bible
inspire endless and varied interpretation.
Once inside this
ever-expanding mountain of commentating and punditing, the
so-called ‘first attempt’: if you do not at some
reasonable point simply walk straight out and away from
the bugger’s clutches (the beggar that is begging your
commentary and never ceasing to beg), i.e., if you do not
at some reasonable moment simply walk away from all your
very own infinitely expanding mountain of commentating and
punditing on the infinitely expanding mountain of
commentating and punditing, the ‘first attempt’, you will
remain inside the mountain lost forever and never will be
able to emerge to be REMADE.
The magic trick that
properly and successfully gets you spit out from the
infinitely expanding mountain called ‘first attempt’, and
back onto your own individual path of remaking, is your
own well-timed walking away from your own infinitely
expanding mountain of punditing and commentating on the
infinitely expanding mountain of punditing and
commentating called ‘first attempt’.
Some
people intending to read it must have been chased off by
this seeming nonsense of a warning, but well-seasoned
pundits who read the warnings laughed like drunken pirates
over a chest of jewels because they ‘loved insanely’ the
‘first attempt’ and all of The Remaking for the way it ‘invited punditrizing
to no end’. And they loved the way Sammy’s
‘revisions’ had made mj’s novum organum a
little amusing at last.
II. Mortimer
in
97. the ‘second
encounter’ was still a live event
Meanwhile
the famous ‘second
encounter of M and J’ which had kicked off in early
November still remained a live event in
It
was not a very successful
live event though. Censorship ratings established by psych
nurses had hardly saved it. And seating had never been
offered to outsiders, of course. Not because it was sold
out; but because only the two principals had been allowed
official entry since day one.
And
yet: “The second encounter was an improvement over
the ‘first encounter’,” as certain pundits said after they
studied and compared The Remaking’s three ‘encounters’
between M and J. It was important that pundits do such
comparative studies, they thought. And it was nice to hear
of ‘improvement’ when you were a pundit, even if
the news came many years after
Most
pundits thought it terribly important what happened to mj
lorenzo, of course, then or now. For they believed that
humanity’s future depended on him, no matter how
improbable or nutty that might sound to friends and
relatives.
To
nurses though, such future wizardry was ‘Monday morning
hockey-coaching’, because in
To
the nurses, the hospital administrator, the medical
records secretary, the patients; to maintenance staff and
even to housekeepers (whether Indian or Eskimo), during
the days that the case dragged on, it looked and felt
like a train wreck.
A
‘Canadian Pacific head-on’, as the administrator said to
the Mountie by phone around mid-afternoon of the first
full day.
“It’s
an American plane
crash,” the chief psych nurse shouted to the Fort
Smith Mountie, whom she knew better than the townspeople
realized. And she sort of grabbed the phone from the
administrator’s hand to say to the Mountie, “Just imagine
if a Cessna
crashed into Six West leaving two twin brothers,
both half-dead, one’s noggin working
without the rest of him, the other’s rest of him but not
noggin. One acting doctor, the other patient, both
wacky and grosser
than moose poop. Each useless to
himself and
the other, less
than useless to the human condition, and I care less who
disagrees, Americans-Brits-French-flippin-Queen-herself, now-or-later.”
98. mj lorenzo’s
official psychiatric history made public
Given
such an unpleasant to-do, then, if Jack Lorenzo’s psych
chart had not included certain important bits of
psychiatric history to help his nurses understand him and
his doctor, and to help them ‘sympathize’, as
psych pundits would say later, it certainly should have. The
‘first
encounter’, as they summarized in the early 70s, had
started in Philly six months back, when finally Jack
Lorenzo had burst out through his other half’s – i.e., Dr.
Mortimer Lorenzo’s – thick but cracking shell; had wiggled
free; and had gotten de-repressed enough to start a
conversation with Mortimer on the street, a back and forth
that all of Powelton Village remembered months and years
later as if yesterday:
"You
think too much!" neighbors had heard, and then, from the
very same mouth, but quietly now, "Well,.... I don't kno-ow," with a
tone that was musical, and a shoulder twist that no one
could forget. And that was Mortimer answering Jack’s
accusation, of course. And so both ‘M’ and ‘J’ had been in
operation at once
and simultaneously at that point, finally, said
pundits, and even talking
to each other, amazingly, for the first time in history.
That
was why in his book, The Remaking, mj
had called it ‘the first encounter of M and J’, as ‘psych
history pundits’ would say when they made it their job to
fill in missing pieces of mj lorenzo’s ‘psychiatric past
history’ and keep it updated as more information came in
year to year. And that ‘first encounter’ had gone on ‘for
a while’, they thought. The meeting between mj’s two
halves had lasted until
the Crack-Up, as a matter of fact. For after that
Jack had gotten complete
control of mj and sent Mortimer packing, technically
and unofficially placing him on ‘un-requested vacation
leave’, as early Remaking savants said with deadpan faces.
And so, Mortimer had gone off ‘flying into the
atmosphere’, as the joke went, ‘for a while’. Because
Mortimer liked ‘airy realms’ so much. And the first
encounter had ended.
So
the ‘first encounter’, you could say, in sum, had
consisted of one very short verbal interchange between ‘M
and J’ that had been echoed and re-echoed, or ‘perseverated’,
as shrink pundits preferred to put it, ’10,000 times at
least’. This psychotic-looking condition had continued for
weeks and had ended in an explosion on the Continental
Divide, thanks to Jack’s far out and – some said – ‘wacky’
and ‘manic’ notions about space-time, and his
self-endangering behaviors based on same. All of which had
lost him his job and professional reputation too, maybe,
and totaled his father’s beautiful car, and driven his
parents mad, and almost killed poor mj
‘and some other people too maybe’, they added.
But
it could have
been worse, opined a few nutty ‘psychoanalytic
psych’ pundits whom the rest of the pundit world found truly trying. “Luckily,” as
these brain-dead head shrinks said, “mj had only been split in
half.” That was what the heartless brains had
pointed out. ‘Only half, not eighths or sixteenths’.
‘OR
TWO HUNDRED FIFTY SIXTHS’, they must have forgotten to
add.
The
one half of mj had ‘merely’
gone off for a ‘little’
while ‘quietly’,
explained these shrinks and student shrinks. And the
‘other half’ had been left ‘working’ ‘pretty
fine’.
‘JUST
WITHOUT GREY MATTER’, normal people wanted to shout, i.e.,
without intellect
or the slightest appreciation of kindergarten-level social
graces. But who needed that, right? The ‘psycho’ pundits
did not, it seemed. Well, then, how long would they like to go
without their
grey matter? Would they like to try four months too?
And: how ‘lucky’ would they feel to be ‘half a person’
themselves?
These
‘psycho’ pundits were insufferable, in other words. They
could use some help recovering from their miserable state,
it seemed. A volunteer or two might be found who could
help them to become ‘half a person’ now if they thought
that being half-personed was a ‘lucky’ thing. And some
irritated pundits did offer in circulated handbills to
‘put these psychoanalytic idiots out of their misery’.
Would they have
wanted to hear such palliation and whitewash of their friend’s
tragic condition, if it had been their best
friend? Would they have wanted to hear such buffalo-flop
analysis about how
much worse it could have been?
Which
99. pundits study
mj’s prior psych history to estimate possible present
danger ‘now’, i.e., during the winter of ’70-‘71
At
any rate, given this particular case history and this
particular ‘first
encounter’, what then might the ‘second
encounter’ have brought mj and the world? This was
what a few pundits asked, looking back, for they believed
that every detail of mj’s remaking year had significance
NOW for the world’s future. And maybe they were nuts, and
maybe not. Maybe they were freaky leftist activists who
had flunked Haute
Underarm Couture 101, but at least they cared about the
whole world, not just themselves. And that was
a nice start for humanity’s remaking.
And
so: how much danger, they asked, might their mj lorenzo
have been in – in the hospital in Fort Smith – and which
part of him was in danger, Mortimer or Jack?
The
sad truth was, they estimated, that Jo Lorenzo must have
been ‘right on the money’ when she had asked these
questions of Rev so demandingly.
For
the kind of danger that might have been expected to result
from any ‘encounter’ or Jungian ‘auseinandersetzung’
2 between Jack and
Mortimer at this point, as the annoying
psycho-whiz-pundits now theorized after the fact, the
likely danger from a
face-to-face meeting and coming-to-terms with each other
in the Fort Smith hospital lay in this, they said,
that: any
discord – or power shifts – between M and J would have
weakened mj’s ability to function as a whole person.
Well.
Alright
then.
They
must have meant that mj was ‘fragile’. But they had
forgotten how to say it properly in English, apparently,
such as: ‘mj lorenzo had crumbled like a cookie and
split completely in half in the past, one time, and he
might crumble the same way OR WORSE now a
second time’.
In
other words, the drastic
shifting of almost all of mj’s power from Mortimer to
Jack during the ‘first encounter’ had
unmasked mj’s essential
psycho-structural fragility and produced
something that looked, from hindsight, like a manic
psychotic break. Which had led to self-endangering
behaviors and even gotten mj almost killed. All of which
had produced, as the psychoanalytic
psychologist-whiz-pundits liked to put it – a bit frozen
and a little bit shakily – a weakening of “mj’s
ability to function as a whole person.”
Which
certainly seemed a prize-winning cretin understatement
when you recalled that he was cracked all
the way through like a bar magnet cut in two halves
with a hacksaw, and his two personality halves now sat
in Fort Smith painfully disconnected in two different
parts of the universe.
But
anyway, following the parallel, and reasoning in the very
same bland and spineless manner, these ‘psycho’ pundits,
these exceedingly psychoanalytic psychologist-whiz pundits
concluded that: now; and presently; during the ‘second
encounter’ in the hospital in Fort Smith; as mj’s two
sides proceeded to relate to each other in whatever sane
or less-than-sane way, and as his two sides theoretically
looked for some common meeting ground for starting
preliminary negotiations: if a major discord
should surface, or if any major shift in power should
result, this ‘would
weaken mj’s ability to function as a whole person’.
But
where did they learn to coldly forewarn dead givens like
this?
WHEN
THE TITANIC SANK
WAS THE NEW YORK TIMES HEADLINE ‘TITANIC MAY HAVE TROUBLE
SAILING’?
Families
of casualties would have thug-mobbed the paper.
Screw
the ‘psychobabble pundits’, the rest of punditry said.
That ‘screwed-up’ sentence about ‘functioning whole
persons’ ‘had a loose screw in it that fell into the
sentence when their psychobabble heads came unscrewed’.
Everybody knew that mj lorenzo’s ability to function in
this world, by the time he had reached
100. could more
Cracked-Up mj’s be out there wandering about? the
pundits asked
The
world was in sad shape, that is, if more mj lorenzos were
out there by chance wandering the planet about to Crack Up.
Many
pundit analysts after thinking about The Remaking in depth
for years, and after exhaustive scientific research and
clinical studies, would conclude there were plenty more such
fragile mj lorenzos around, especially right in the
And
the world was in worse
shape to whatever extent mj’s hunch (and the pundits’)
might have been right, that the human race entire,
especially Western civilization; and most of all mj’s
country; each and every person; was dangerously close to
becoming like one half of mj or the other, Mortimer or
Jack. If that were the case, then improper and
unhealthy distribution of Mortimer and Jack energy
anywhere in the world, to whatever extent it occurred,
could lead to institutions and governments and
organizations of all kinds having to make the same
impossible choice mj had been forced to make: between
psycho-fragile ideology-dominated leadership (like
Mortimer had been); and burnt-out-manic-y, speed-freaky,
whittled-to-id type leadership (like Jack).
This
was the way most pundits thought about it already by the
mid-seventies.
It was why they took The Remaking so seriously, irritatingly
seriously at times. They did not see The Remaking’s
significance as psychological only, i.e., as mj’s private
psych-split thing only. The Remaking’s implications, for
the pundits, were psychological AND political on a global
scale; and they knew that this had been mj lorenzo’s
comprehension of the matter too when he had been writing
The Remaking.
101. could mj
lorenzo be an avatar? the pundits wanted to know and
(though it made their
sanity seem questionable too now) they interviewed mj’s
parents for clues to the answer
It
started hitting some Harvard divinity school pundits at
this level, too, during the mid-seventies. They and their
cronies agreed the implications were not just individual
and psychological, but also ‘political on a grand scale’.
Secretly they meant also ‘religious’, but
they had agreed not to use this word publicly yet.
This
very special and vocal punditry group felt mj lorenzo
resembled a messiah or avatar in some ways; but they felt
it was not the right time to go public with that shocker.
Maybe he was a ‘culture hero’, some thought, a charismatic
spiritual leader like Joseph Campbell wrote about.4
Maybe he was one who could save the world from cataclysm;
unless they too were going half-crazy.
After
thinking about it long enough to get over some shock at
the idea, they decided to find out more about mj’s past.
Who in the world was
this mj lorenzo? How could he mirror creation so? How
might he have guessed he did so, and gone examining
himself therefore, and gone reporting such incredible
results? Who in God’s name had told him to do these
things?
With
such questions in mind, a group of pundits looked up mj’s
parents, since mj had made no effort to hide their
whereabouts. Nor had Rev. He had asked people to call him
if they found his son, and they knew from The Remaking
that the Lorenzos lived in the one and only Methodist
parsonage in the small country town of Florence in
Burlington County, New Jersey, which lay right on the
Delaware River below Trenton.
They
wanted to talk to mj lorenzo himself in the worst way
about all of this, of course, in those first years after
they discovered The Remaking; but Sammy Martinez refused
to tell them where mj was living. Mj still ‘needed space’,
he insisted. And he made them promise not to ask mj's
parents.
And
so a group of about thirty psychology, sociology,
anthropology, history, religion and political science
pundits from Penn, Princeton, Haverford, Swarthmore,
Villanova, Ursinus and several other east coast campuses
visited the Lorenzos and took – from mj’s parents – a sort
of combined psychosocial history and one-world-religion
history of mj’s life, meeting with the Lorenzos right in
the church basement’s main hall used for the bigger Sunday
School classes.
And
this history should have been on Jack’s hospital chart
too, of course, as psych history pundits said, but it came
too late. Maybe mj lorenzo’s two sides, Mortimer and Jack,
would have been greeted more warmly had the nurses only
known the story which the Lorenzos told, that mj had
always seemed to be emotionally stable as the happy little
boy shown in family photos. He had gotten through high
school with no crises, mainly by keeping his nose in a
book, for he always was good at that. But at Wrigley in
the early sixties he had fallen into depression, as his
Remaking missives showed. And soon he had chafed at the
tightly tied bonds of family, church and society, as the
pundits knew already. And his fear of what might happen if
he broke those bonds had worsened the depression again and
again.
Then
when his country had become so violently polarized between
right and left during the late sixties and had nearly
pulled apart at the seams, the split in that outer world
had paralleled mj’s own inner split between Mortimer and
Jack exactly.
This was what the pundits realized after listening to Rev
and Jo: exactly;
reverberating
distressingly inside him in sympathy with both sides of
his divided country and self; rattling him more than
he already was rattled and weakening his Mortimer
defenses, until finally it lit a fire under the ‘Jack’
inside him, incubated him all the way to the
Jack-in-the-box pop-out stage, and ultimately energized
and provoked Jack to action.
And
when Jack had finally burst free from
inside Mortimer for the first time; when Jack did finally gain
control of mj during his internship at Presbyterian
Hospital in W. Philly, and when Jack then demanded in May
and June of ’70 that mj’s humanity be set free totally, at
once, to find its
own way of being human, and really human this
time, not sham human; and when that breaking free
eventually triggered mj’s trip west: the immediate first
result of Jack’s escaping from Mortimer’s surrounding
shell prison and of Jack’s seizing control of mj, even
before mj left on his trip west, long before, was: that
mj was rendered
so FRAGILE he looked schizophrenic. And FRAGILITY
remained a constant pressing issue every single day
thereafter, for at least a year, and probably
longer, maybe even for many years.
Certainly
in
Mj’s
emotional state during the entire year of The Remaking,
therefore, was like that of a nation undergoing a
revolution, a nation whose revolution rendered it
incapable of conducting normal day-to-day affairs; or, was
like that of a surgery patient whose surgery saved him
from dying but left him robbed of returning to normal life
indefinitely. In other words, as with fragile
102. pundits
discover that the one at risk from Crack-Up or
‘fragility’ was and is Mortimer, not Jack
And
so, said the ‘psych history pundits’, Jack had free rein
to remake mj lorenzo for a whole summer, until Freeze-Up
struck in November. And by this time Jack was burnt out
from the effort. And suddenly psycho-fragile
ideology-obsessed Mortimer was the only part of mj still
‘functioning’. And suddenly Mortimer found himself ‘in
charge of’ a strung out and whittled-to-id,
non-functioning Jack, at the hospital in
Mortimer
would have preferred the old days when Jack had been
locked up inside of him, for he had known how to control
everything about that unpredictable animal. But he put
whatever heart and soul he could into helping this
pathetic, newly liberated Jack, since Jack was one
half of his own mj self, come to think of it, though
Mortimer was ashamed to admit it. And he tried for two whole
weeks to help.
Yet
Mortimer’s forte was intellect, not
heart and soul. So his efforts were undone at once by mj’s
‘fragility’,
i.e., by Jack’s theoretical
fragility, his appearance of having broken completely;
and by Mortimer’s own undeniable fragility
as well. Because anyone who sensed psychic fragility in
another or in oneself always tended to get nervous and all
the more
fragile, and eventually could get destabilized for that
reason alone, and finally even undone, if he or she lacked
the emotional fortitude to flow with and withstand it, and
not be bowled over by it. And Mortimer had no emotional
fortitude whatever. Zilch. By definition.
All
this fragility in mj lorenzo had been a part of him since
the very beginning, by the way. It had been caused by the
manner in which his two sides had been sketched out on the
drawing board and assigned value from the very day John
Calvin had revolutionized and reformed the medieval Roman
church’s theology and religious practice. Right off the
bat Calvin had drawn on inspiration from the early church
fathers and attempted to suppress human sexuality and many
other forms of naturally human self-expression.
Interestingly, though: if anything, even though those who
practiced extremist Reform Protestantism thought it the
ultimate kind of Christianity ever, its theology had come
to look to modern observers even more
personality-polarizing than late-medieval and
early-Renaissance European Catholic life had been, as
divinity pundits said.
So,
mj lorenzo’s split had followed the big conceptual trend
lines that had been laid out on the drawing board by his Christian
Western world ever since the day when that world view
had been born. The fragility, in other words, had not
come from genes or from pre-birth trauma or from any
kind of rearing that the Lorenzos’ church culture would
have considered abusive or unusual. This was the
conclusion of the ‘one-world-religion pundits’ after they
had thought about their meeting with the Lorenzos for
about a year and spent some coffee breaks with psych and
divinity pundits. They studied the matter in depth and
with breadth over years, in journals and in classrooms,
and especially studied what mj had offered on the subject
right in The Remaking and its revisions. And later
generations of pundits agreed with them vehemently that mj’s fragility had
been inherited, not from his parents’ genes –
for they and their ancestors had all been seen as quite
normal and therefore ‘sane’ within their Calvinist and
Methodist and Church of England contexts – but from his crazy
extremist-Protestant Western-world culture at large.
And
this thoroughly researched understanding in no time became
– and forever remained – an underpinning universal tenet
of the unwritten Remaking pundit credo and constitution.
All
of this earthshaking insight was too late for mj, though.
His two halves had already, both of them, run rampant in a
hospital in
Jack,
for his part, was hard to read at
Outsiders
who read The Remaking later observed, correctly, that 99%
of the abilities needed for withstanding and enjoying
relationship of any kind lay on Jack’s side of the
duality, not Mortimer’s, making Jack the stronger one,
even as weak and sick as he looked at the moment in Fort
Smith. Mortimer may have been sheriff of the shire of
Brains, but Jack was sheriff of the Everything-Human-but-Brains shire.
And that was what counted, even if the notion surprised or
shocked some people: intellect was not
a requirement for friendship. Intellect was
not required for life, for that matter, or the planet’s
animals would have died out long ago. Whereas Jack’s
‘everything else but intellect’ WAS absolutely
essential for friendship or relationship of any
kind, therapeutic or otherwise, including: Jack’s
animal comfort with his body; the ease with which he
experienced and used emotion; his love of adventure and
exploring the world, including the adventure of exploring
relationship; his intuitive skill in a relationship or in
any natural human setting. These were just a few of the
thousands of strengths that had ended up somehow being
borne by the mis-measured ‘half’ of mj called ‘Jack’; who
was really more like ninety nine per
cent of mj’s strengths and humanity, not
merely ‘half’ as The Remaking often implied. Mortimer
possessed none of these very essential skills for being
human, with the result that Mortimer, while a heroically willing
therapist at first, was an exceedingly feeble one in the
doing, since he had little to offer besides tons of lofty
braininess and a weird knack with rules.
And
so, not surprisingly, Mortimer, after two weeks of
‘therapy’ in the form of daily written intellectual
analysis of: ‘Mortimer’; and ‘Jack’; had failed to get even a sigh
out of Jack. Whereas, and worse, out of himself Mortimer
had gotten to feeling overwhelmed and debilitated. And more so every day.
Profoundly weakened by something he could not identify, by
something happening inside of him. And Mortimer,
consequently, feared HE TOO might go crazy, and longed to
get to
103. Mortimer
disqualified (after the fact; and too late) from
practicing psychiatry on self
Mortimer
had toughed it out for those two long emotionally
exhausting weeks at
That
was how some of the more experienced psychiatrist pundits
put it, at least. And Sammy Martinez and the Dr. weighed
in on the subject too, eventually, and agreed. Years later
Dr. Lorenzo added that Mortimer’s ‘dearth of humanity’
explained why extremist Western-world Mortimer-type
Protestant zealots tended to create havoc on all sides
instead of peace whenever they visited the non-Western
world trying to do nice ‘democratic and Christian’ things
for people. They tended to be like the Wrigley College
graduates who went to Colombian jungles as missionaries
and got their heads literally chopped off, literally
shrunk, and literally worn as a bangle
talisman on witch-doctors’ dark brown chests.
And
an even bigger error was this, said psych pundits: that
someone with no human
strength but intellect
should ever have been trying to treat his own self,
especially when that ‘own self’ was as regressed as Jack;
as depressed, mute and sexually provocative; as
historically threatening toward the half-self now
doctoring; and as psychotic, probably, even, as Jack was
right then. The hospital never should have
assigned Mortimer the case, since the patient was
his very own self, and 99% of that very own
self; and
psychotic. Mortimer was bound
to be unnerved and undone in the first five
minutes if not sooner, by trying to treat his own psychotic other
‘half’, i.e., his other 99% actually. And any number of
terrible outcomes were guaranteed, said the
psychologist and psychiatrist pundits, especially those
who knew the clinically
heavy end of the field.
Thus
the ‘danger’ predicted by mj lorenzo’s psych
history was not to Jack but to Mortimer
at this point, said the pundits. And they were right about
this, as some
ex-Anna-Freud people in
104. Mortimer’s
writing during the ‘second encounter’ in late November
reflects his sense of impending disintegration and
pundits explain why
It
was hardly surprising then, that Rev and Jo found
Mortimer’s writing at this point in the year barely
comprehensible. Later pundit readers who were more
objective and qualified than the Lorenzos said that all of
Mortimer’s writing during his two weeks at Fort Smith,
including the ‘first attempt’, while not necessarily
‘incomprehensible’, did reveal that he felt a sense of impending
disintegration.
They
blamed the raunchy, smelly instinctual male animal
presence of Jack in the tiny, stuffy seclusion room. They
blamed Mortimer’s ‘lack of humanity’. And too, they blamed
Mortimer’s over-developed talent for intellectually
imagining what might be going on inside that silent,
un-talkative instinct-driven animal, Jack. Because,
silence in others always
unnerved people who were emotionally fragile and also
highly imaginative, said certain psycho-pundits. And they
were right.
But
even more factors than just these three were ‘causing’
Mortimer’s disarray. After all, was this not the same Jack who
had been sending Mortimer messages of brotherly love all
summer, mixed with death
threats, as his ‘gut’ had instructed him to
do? And had not Jack said that for mj lorenzo to be
‘reborn’, a part of
mj would first have to die, and he preferred
it were Mortimer? And Jack certainly was the
self-fancied poet who had written the lines,
If I were to
ask you your origins, Mortimer
If I were to
beat you to porridge or pemmican
If I were to rape an
incorrigible Indian….5
So
any outsider had to be left wondering why Mortimer even risked entering
the cell without at least three brute male aids, techs, or
guards, or naked Indians with tomahawks, always as backup
help. In case Jack, on impulse, attempted to act on any
one of these past and various threats, each one well documented
in certain letters sent to parents. It would have been
standard hospital psych policy. Was Mortimer unconsciously
suicidal maybe? Was he so hypnotized and enamored of his
animal ‘other half’, Jack, that he could not think
straight? Was he telling himself that Jack could or would
not ever hurt him, not his very own other half? If so, he was
deluding himself.
Mortimer’s
writing to his parents in the ‘first attempt’, said the
pundits, showed exactly how rattled he was. He wrote of
whirlpools, splits, ‘crashing and drowning’; and needing
to get his feet back on the ground. Then of
disintegration, ‘scattered pieces’; and again, whirlpools.
And he equated Jack with ‘a whirlpool’, partly because
Mackenzie’s journals described a famous whirlpool in the
river between Fort Smith and Fort Chipewyan, and so
whirlpools were on his mind for that reason; but mainly
because Jung wrote about the ‘Whirlpool of Life’
as opposed to the ‘Rock of Thought’, a dichotomy
Jung had pulled from ancient Greek myth.6
And Mortimer was reading Jung throughout the winter. And
it was life that Mortimer feared, not thought.
That was why he said he wanted to be somewhere else, far
from the ‘whirlpool’. He wanted to be in a ‘border area’ a
little higher up the river which meant – logically
speaking – closer to the mountains where all the massive
amounts of water flowing restlessly across the open
northern plains would be less frightening, where he could
feel more grounded and stable, feet-on-the-ground, and
work on ‘This Book’, his rock of thought for the moment.
But by ‘water’ and ‘whirlpool’ he really meant the water
of life, meaning Jack, and life with Jack in the world.
“A
mandala is an antidote to a chaotic state of mind,” he
chanted day and night. For Mortimer’s book, his
‘word-mandala’, like every mandala ever produced in human
history, was a device for meditatively ‘centering’ and
calming oneself.
Then
he listed the frightening things he imagined
to be going on inside
the whirlpool called Jack, despite the fact
that Jack was not saying a word, but only
compulsively exciting his pleasure centers. He saw Jack
as: ‘younger brother’, ‘Indian brave’, ‘Black Jack’;
‘bigger than I’, ‘less predictable’, and ‘given to
excessive outbreaks’. He even called Jack ‘a sick fumbling
idiot wrecked by a car crash’; ‘out of hand’, and
‘seductive’; and finally, once again, ‘a whirlpool’.
105. leftist
political pundits gain hope from Jack’s devastating
impact on Mortimer
‘Jack did not have to be
functioning or sane, even, to do Mortimer in’, the leftover radical
60’s-leftist pundits loved to observe in their political
rag sheets in the early 70’s. Because Jack, as they saw,
enjoyed an inordinate balance of power when it came to the
psychological
part of the warfare.
He could be locked up in a psych ward psychotic, and still his chief
enemy remained dizzy with fear of him. The extreme
political leftists among the pundits in the early 70s,
those who felt discouraged by Richard Nixon’s sympathy for
the extreme right and by his blackballing and persecution
of left-leaners including incomparable artists and
political activists like folksinger Pete Seeger, got tremendous
mileage out of this discovery. It gave them hope again.
They had never had any way of measuring which of their
political approaches worked best, and now suddenly they
saw that certain kinds of psychological warfare could be
the best weapons of all.
Why? Because the Mortimers
of the world were less at home with their animal nature
than the Jacks were with theirs, and therefore could be
spooked with
animal energy far more easily than the Jacks could.
The Remaking taught them that. And they believed it.
Whenever they studied the notion on their own, abroad in
the world, away from Remaking workshops and
co-conspirators, they found plenty of corroborating
evidence to support the hypothesis. And so it became a
platitude. But they thanked mj lorenzo for having opened
their eyes to it in a formally philosophical and
unforgettable way.
106. naturally
Mortimer chooses the rock of thought over the whirlpool
of life
And
so it should have come as no surprise to anyone in the
world that Mortimer now started writing with more longing
for the island in Lake Athabasca (a few miles from Ft.
Chipewyan) where he would love to spend the winter,
preferring it, naturally, to Fort Smith. Since
Thus
he wrote at the time:
Scylla
and
Charybdis are the opposites which symbolize the split,
the duality, the polarity upon which my (Mortimer’s;
Jack’s; mj’s) forward
movement oscillates, upon which it may
either crash or drown. (After his crack-up on solid
ground, Jack takes to the water, then at
But
such visions will remove
the seer from his firm and rocky earth. They are
the brief soul-explosions
by which the secrets of the universe reveal themselves
and strike him with unusual power. He needs to get his feet back on the
ground. He enters
I
(Mortimer; Jack; mj) enter
I
Enter
The
disintegration
of the blue Buick, like the disintegration of Mortimer
and Jack under the dubious auspices of each other, is
merely a secondary
blast, the first
one having occurred at birth. The
re-entry into ‘the
world’ (of Alberta) is not a complete return of
scattered pieces, either, as “the petals are still
drifting earthward;” and since it is certain that
only ‘in this
world’ do the best and highest highs occur, so
that if Fort
Smith is ‘the world’ (and for Mortimer, is
Jack), and if ‘the world’, and Jack, are the
whirlpool down into which Mortimer is now descending
from high in the sky, rapidly,
then
(
in
a sense
we never do come down completely
from the great blast-off
(high) of birth
and
each rebirth is only a secondary firing
which
detains
us up there (high) longer
it is therefore in a
border area somewhere
that we hope to stay
both
in
contact
with the ground
(world)
and
(high)
in
the sky
maybe
that’s
why
only on the fringe of some
airy mountain range
can
we ever seem content with ourselves
there
where
earth
and
sky
BOTH
filter
through
skin and guts and lungs
into
our blood
and
shunt
past brain
far
down to our bleeding feet
to
make them walk in the direction
that
we have had revealed to us as
—as
in a dream—
ours
Rose Window = Window of My Soul (who coined that
phrase?) = My Own Mandala = The Way Up = The Way Back
Down from Being Up
= This Book
Hungabee (up close) = Peace Rose (ecstasy) = Rose
Window (explosion as ecstasy) = The mountain itself is the
way down
These
lines revealed, as ‘astrology’ pundits liked to chime,
that mj lorenzo knew that a well-proportioned, fully human
‘life’ had to
balance elements of water, earth, air and fire. His
reference to the ‘four elements’ in his writing at times,
they said, showed that his conceptual world was ‘filling
in and firming up’ slowly as the year progressed. His
personal philosophical system was ‘starting to gel’. And
‘the fringe of some airy mountain range’ would be where he
might eventually, one day (maybe in spring),
accomplish such a balanced unity. BUT NOT NOW. OR HERE.
For here and now, anyway, he felt ‘safer’ choosing the
pure ‘rock of thought’: ‘This Book’.
107. pundits wake
up to The Remaking’s world of Native American myth
Mortimer’s
drastic language of ‘exploding mountains’, ‘soul
explosions’, ‘epiphany’, ‘rebirth blast-off’, and so on,
he employed to
portray graphically his feeling that he was unready for drastic
involvement in life.
The
violent imagery here and elsewhere, especially in the
Triptique, came mainly from a Hare tribal legend in
Petitot’s book, a tale mj included eventually at the end
of The Remaking, in ‘Lake O’Hara’, without comment,
calling it his ‘Second Dream’ from Hungabee.7
In
the tale two Dene-Hare brothers spent a lifetime competing
for power, drifted apart therefore and met again in old
age ‘by chance’, regretted their lifelong error and vowed
to ‘repair man’. They ‘entered the mountain’ together this
time, which swelled and ‘exploded’, and they came out
together as children again to start all over again with a
new life in a new world, working together
this time, instead of competing for power and
resources. The tale explained that from this story
had come the expression once well-known among northern
tribes: “THE ROCKY MOUNTAINS REMADE MAN.”
One
of the most revealing events of Remaking punditry history
was how ALL of the magnificently brilliant pundits of the
Western world for decades had managed to overlook this
seminal source for mj lorenzo’s Remaking imagery, even
down to the title word ‘remaking’. Jack had said again and
again that he had immersed himself in Petitot’s northern
Indian tales. And mj had left this tale word for word in
the final dramatic climax of his book. And yet the pundits
had missed the hint.
The
hint lay there for twenty years, pundits trapsing over it
back and forth millions of times, until finally a new
young pundit noticed it in the early nineties, shocking
and shaming the older pundit world. And suddenly that
incredibly hip and stellar world had to confess it never had taken
the Remaking’s Indian tales seriously, in reality.
And
the pundit world was embarrassed.
An
‘Indian myth’ school of punditry materialized overnight.
Yet, all the more astonishing, almost as many decades had
to pass again before ‘myth pundits’ finally noticed that
this legend contained
at least as many large chunks of The Remaking story
line as Mackenzie’s Journals did, a different
set of chunks: two
polar opposite ‘brothers’, first working disjointedly in
the world, realized their mistakes and requested the
chance for a new life and were given it. They ‘went up
into’ the
It
was the story line of mj lorenzo’s Remaking!!!
And
so, the universe of punditry was shocked ALMOST TO DEATH
by their own almost incurable blindness caused by Western
world culture-bias. And suddenly, therefore, there was a
concerted effort to dig to the bottom of all Native
American tales mj had used. And starting in the nineties a
fad developed among newer Remaking pundits to discredit
‘early Remaking pundits’ and add themselves to a growing
number who disbelieved mj lorenzo had gone north OR west,
either one, and who believed instead that, with help from
Petitot’s Indian tales and Mackenzie’s journals and other
sources, all probably borrowed from the Philadelphia
Public Library, mj lorenzo, as they said, had ‘ripped off
his plot’ and written
The Remaking (as he had ‘virtually admitted’ at the
end of the book in these lines:) ‘in a room in
smoggy W. Philly’, “with windows open… to the
periodic sonic boom of Lester’s black ’52 Continental,
picked up in Maryland for $50 and hangared behind my
decrepit Volkswagen with its blue-green flower sticker…”
108. Mortimer vows
to leave
Wiser,
more experienced pundits, many of them of that ‘early
Remaking pundit’ fame, reminded these contentious upstarts
that mj lorenzo’s physical location in ’70-’71 made little
difference in the end. Regardless of where or how mj’s
book had been written, they said, its wisdom reigned
undiminished.
At
the
But
regardless of where mj lorenzo spent his Remaking year,
said the old-timer pundits in later years, they had to
admit they liked the graphic way he had told his story of
getting distance
from himself.
Mortimer
knew he was ‘in
Mortimer
was ‘getting out of Dodge’ and explained himself as
follows:
But
the greatest split
of all is the one between the hitherto more usual
me, ‘Mortimer’, and that now suddenly silent younger
brother of mine, that Indian brave and Black Jack who is
bigger than I and less predictable, more given to
excessive outbursts like the one of the past few months.
(Would that he could have seen the truth as I, Mortimer,
have seen it, here at
I’ve
crossed
the imaginary line into
Here
is what Alexander Mackenzie says about the Indians of
the
It is on such an island
in
And
after a few pages of intellectual acrobatics about the
difficulty of getting Jack and Mortimer lined up properly
for a reunion, Mortimer returned to the subject of his new
plan of leaving
Since
my suspended argument with the rapids (they froze up
before I could make peace with them), I have decided to
‘portage’ straight to
If
the river’s freezing means the Freezing-Up of Jack the
seducer, then Break-Up will mean his liberation again…..
And once more, after a few more
pages:
….I
gladly
leave behind a world of melodrama, of overactive acting,
of psychotic hyperkinesia and explosion, and enter the
island cabin I have chosen on this frozen
Mortimer
1 See
final chapter of the present work entitled ‘
2 Auseinandersetzung:
see the concluding half of '
3 Freud
divided the personality into three parts: id, ego and
superego. The id was the animal part, full of animal instinct
and especially animal sexuality under biological pressure for
expressive release, whether the ego or superego liked it or
not.
4
Joseph Campbell, in The Hero with a Thousand Faces
(Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1949), explored the
universal human phenomenon of culture hero,
studying the lives and teachings of spiritual and/or
charismatic leaders of various cultures who had led their
people out of crisis at a particular point in their history.
5 In
‘The Fort Simpson package (September)’, section 44.
6 The
Greek myth of Scylla and Charybdis, Scylla being the name of
the Mythical Rock, and Charybdis that of the Mythical
Whirlpool which lay right beside it; so that boat steersmen
trying to thread that scary needle had to remember second to
second that if they pulled to one side even just a few
millimeters too many to avoid one danger, they were falling
into the trap of the other danger. See the chapter 'third
attempt' for more on how Jung used these conceptual handles in
his blockbuster, Symbols of
Transformation.